The Sly Perfidy of People Who Say They Care…

Clovis, Editorial cartoon, Jamaica Observer June 12, 2014

This editorial cartoon in the Jamaica Observer of June 12 featuring a schoolboy in a chastity belt responds to the alleged rape of a male jogger that was sensationally reported in a previous issue of the paper. Questions have been raised about the sketchy details available, suggesting the incident might have been staged to fuel the moral panic instigated by the evangelical right in Jamaican society.

Jamaica is in the throes of a full blown moral panic. Three times a week since mid-May demonstrators clad in black have been assembling in front of the University of the West Indies (UWI), praying and carrying placards urging passers-by to honk in support of their campaign. Some have even taped their mouths to signal that this is a freedom of speech issue.

If you guessed that the protest might have something to do with the serious ills threatening this Caribbean society—rampant criminality, paedophilia, human and narco-trafficking, extra-judicial killings by the police and a crippling national debt among others—you would be wrong. The protest is indirectly fuelled by fear that an international ‘gay lobby’ is gaining ground in Jamaica as manifested by the termination of contract of a former UWI Professor from his post as head of  the Caribbean HIV/AIDS Regional Training Network or CHART as it is popularly known.

According to the University of the West Indies, CHART CEO Brendan Bain had to be removed from his leadership position after the majority of stakeholders in that organization declared they had no confidence in Bain’s leadership anymore. What prompted the no confidence vote was testimony provided by Bain in a Belize court case, on behalf of a Church group that was arguing for the retention of that country’s buggery laws. This was felt to be in direct contradiction of CHART’s mandate to improve delivery of HIV treatment in the region by reducing the stigma attached to the disease. There is widespread medical consensus based on extensive research that stigmatization and intolerance of men who have sex with men (MSMs) have helped to intensify the spread of the disease as those afflicted with it are afraid to ask for medical help. The Caribbean and sub-Saharan Africa which have the highest rates of HIV infection in the world are irrefutable proof of this.

Disregarding these facts Bain’s supporters have turned the situation into a circus about freedom of speech. Their contention? That Bain should have been free to give expert evidence based on his “research” and that by rescinding his contract the university had bowed to the dictates of an internationally constituted “gay agenda”.

Clovis, Jamaica Observer editorial cartoon, June 19, 2014. A depiction of the so-called 'hijacking' of morality by Jamaicans for Justice and their sex education curriculum for institutionalized children.

Clovis, Jamaica Observer editorial cartoon, June 19, 2014. A depiction of the so-called ‘hijacking’ of morality by Jamaicans for Justice and their sex education curriculum for institutionalized children.

Jamaica’s leading newspapers have provided daily fodder to support these protests in the form of provocative anti-gay cartoons, columns and articles. An atmosphere of near hysteria prevails with all the radio stations besieged by callers self-righteously denouncing the ‘gay agenda’ that is about to derail this virtuous, God-loving country. Virtually every day another scandal rocks the nation. A male jogger is raped by a gang of men! A few days later a 16-year old boy who tried to buy a tube of lipstick is nearly lynched by a mob and has to be rescued by the Police. Practically the next day Jamaicans for Justice, the local human rights group, is accused of attempting to “sexually groom” minors in the state’s care by providing them with special text books modified to include information on anal and oral sex.

JFJbackdoordeal.

Improbably a morning radio host on Newstalk 93 claims that the furore over sex education has NOTHING to do with homosexuality or gay rights and everything to do with the rights of poor, vulnerable children. Yet such concern for children’s rights and for the welfare of children in state homes is unprecedented. Was such a declaration made when the sexual violence that is the norm at these homes was exposed in the media a mere two months ago? Are these armchair moralists aware that the majority of children at these farcical ‘places of safety’ are routinely buggered and raped, often by adult staff members? Where was the disproportionate outrage now being displayed over the education of these children when the Jamaica Observer detailed the kind of sexual abuse young boys in one particular home were subject to?

According to a story by Karyl Walker in the Observer of April 9, 2014:

Horror stories of rape and sexual predation have long haunted children’s homes and one former student of the institution told the Observer that he had been raped by older boys many times during his stay there.

“The big boys rape the smaller boys, and when the smaller boys grow up they rape those who are weaker than them. It never stop,” the former ward said.

More recently, on June 9, 2014, Christopher Pryce wrote an anguished letter to the editor about what he called the ‘Boko Haramisation’ Of Jamaica’s children highlighting the alarming rate at which children are disappearing from their family homes.

Did crusading Christians undertake dramatic demonstrations against the government for its abject dereliction of duty in regulating children’s safety in these instances? Why not? Or does it reserve such protests for socially prominent members of high society who are removed from their cushy jobs?

If there is indeed such widespread concern over the education of children why don’t we express the same angst over the rape and buggery of their little bodies? The lessons in horror these children are taught, come not from any textbook smuggled into the curriculum by ‘the gay lobby’ but as a result of the vile predations of those entrusted with their care. Yet such flagrant violations earn no reaction– let alone action–from the innumerable Christian pulpits dotting this island or the churches braying so vigorously on behalf of Bain’s so-called rights.

Our Churches deal exclusively with the spirit such blatantly skewed reactions seem to say. We don’t care if your children are starving or being turned into sex slaves but rest assured we will police what their young minds and spirits are fed with the fervour of Ayatollahs. Your spiritual health is safe in our holy hands. For material well-being apply to your nearest Don and if necessary yield up your pubescent girl children. Remain confident that such children will go to their sexual slaughter with minds unsullied by the truth. Hallelujah! Pass the collection plate!

20 thoughts on “The Sly Perfidy of People Who Say They Care…

  1. This article is ignoring the ongoing and fervent work done by the Christians she is berating. Nevertheless, she isolates a handful of protesters who are decrying the unjustifiable termination of an individual and extrapolates it to all who oppose homosexuality. So the “moralists” she describes are no different than the skewed morality she is trying to promote where homosexuality should not only be condoned, but celebrated.

      • My views were not meant to be unbiased. It was meant to be critical, accurate and have the intention to show you a vantage that may have eluded you. My views are biased, your views are biased, what really matters is what is true and can we truly tolerate both sides of the argument.

    • Do you live here Jerome? Because we’re not talking about a handful of protesters. It’s a well-organized, well-funded, well-equipped bunch with enormous influence in Jamaica. So for example tomorrow morning Rev Al Miller, yes the same one who was caught while driving/escorting the fugitive don, Dudus during the biggest manhunt this country has ever known, is going to add his considerably popular voice to the protests in front of UWI. And as I mentioned the media here has been in full support all along. So no extrapolation is necessary. The protest is all-pervasive in Jamaican society. What boggles the mind is the disproportionate outrage when you consider the number of children being raped and abducted here daily without so much of a hiss or a boo from the evangelical right here.

      I’m not going to continue this conversation because I simply don’t have the time. Just want to thank you for your comments and the attempt at dialogue.

      and btw no one is asking for homosexuals to be celebrated. Wherever did you get that from? What is being demanded is that they not be discriminated against. Tolerance amounts to celebration in your vocabulary?

  2. Freedom of speech is but a convenient smokescreen for those promoting an agenda of christian self righteousness to hide behind.
    I read the JFJ course material and see nothing there to be ashamed of. What we should all be ashamed of is the abuse – including sexual abuse – in children’s homes and more generally in this society where vulnerable children are apparently considered fair game.

  3. Thank you for this on-point analysis. The images from Clovis help show that this cartoonist is unworthy of the credit he is given as some sort of genius “social critique” for the masses. In a few years, we will surely look back on this filth as we do the racist Sambo cartoons of 50 years ago– but Jamaicans can’t see that yet unfortunately. #BringBackOurBain lol.

  4. I can’t with the Jamaican masses. If the Jamaican social and societal norms continue on this path without shifting the focus to what REALLY MATTERS, within the next decade they are going to find that they are left FARTHER behind than they already are today. Granny Nanny and Marcus Garvey are rolling in their graves… SMH

  5. Pingback: How a Protest to Reinstate a University Professor Relaunched Jamaica’s Gay Rights Debate | Freedom, Justice, Equality News

  6. Pingback: No Science is Neutral : A long hard look at Bain’s Affidavit and the Aftermath   | Groundation Grenada

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s